Get Change, Chance, and Optimality PDF

By April McMahon

ISBN-10: 0198241259

ISBN-13: 9780198241256

This booklet is ready how languages switch. it's also a devastating critique of Optimality Theory-the dominant thought in modern phonology and more and more influential all through linguistics. the writer units out its foundation rules and indicates it to be incapable of explaining both language switch or edition. OT will depend on the innateness of definite human language schools and for this reason must clarify the origins of allegedly genetically-specified positive aspects. Professor McMahon considers the character and evolution of the human language means, and divulges a profound mismatch among the predictions of evolutionary biology and the claims for innateness made in OT. She argues extra that any convincing concept of linguistic switch needs to take account of the jobs of heritage and likelihood. - ;This e-book is set how languages switch. it's also a devastating critique of a frequent linguistic orthodoxy. April McMahon argues that to supply a powerful clarification of linguistic swap the jobs of background and contingency has to be accommodated in linguistic thought. She additionally exhibits that theoretical paintings in comparable disciplines can be utilized to evaluate the worth of such theories. Optimality idea, or OT because it is generally referred to as, dominates modern phonology, in particular within the united states, and is turning into more and more influential in syntax and language acquisition. Having set out its foundation ideas, Professor McMahon assesses their explanatory energy in analysing language switch and its residues in present phonological platforms. utilizing cross-linguistic facts, and drawing comparisons with different theories in and out linguistics, she exhibits that OT is incapable of accounting for language switch, with out the addition of ideas and an appreciation of probability and ancient contingency that might then undermine its theoretical underpinnings. OT depends on innateness and wishes to debate the origins of allegedly genetically-specified beneficial properties. the writer considers the character and evolution of the human language skill, and demonstrates a profound mismatch among the predictions of evolutionary biology and the claims for innateness made in OT. - ;This ambitious critique of Optimality conception (OT) will be required analyzing for all graduate scholars in linguistics. Phonologists of each stripe - synchronic and diachronic, whatever the theories within which they paintings - forget about it at their peril. a person with even a passing curiosity in linguistic thought could even be good steered to learn it, simply because its implications succeed in way past phonology to contain present hypotheses concerning the nature and evolution of human language ... this quantity should still solidfy McMahon's attractiveness as essentially the most insightful linguistic theorists at present writing. - normal Linguistics;A serious contribution to the controversy on how Optimality conception money owed (or can't account) for old swap ... a troublesome and lengthy examine the claims and practices of OT. - Years paintings in English Studies;A wonderful ebook, elegantly argued and deftly written. a huge theoretical critique, confronting Optimality concept and different formalist innatist paradigms with the realities of evolutionary biology and neuroscience. essentially the most very important and complicated works in phonological thought of the previous couple of a long time. - Roger Lass, college of Cape city

Show description

Read or Download Change, Chance, and Optimality PDF

Best foreign language study & reference books

Download PDF by Chen Ru, Wang Tianhui: Chinese Situational Dialogues

The ebook is for foreigners to profit spoken chinese language. by way of humans job scenario, the freshmen can research spoken chinese language simply, and clutch the day-by-day verbal exchange of chinese language progressively.

Additional resources for Change, Chance, and Optimality

Example text

This change, however, may add a layer of complexity, since the sympathy candidate and selector constraint are still necessary, and the faithfulness constraints which would have acted as sympathy constraints are presumably still available innately, albeit no longer susceptible to marking as However, ®SYM is now also independently required, and its status is unclear: although it is stated as a constraint, it seems to operate more like an algorithm, so that its ranking and violability come into question.

Most notably, if we maintain a parallel conception of Gen, which will then provide all possible output candidates, and if disparate correspondence constraints can then in principle link any possible input with any possible output, it is hard to see how the resulting theory could claim restrictiveness, let alone parsimony. Such a model will be equivalent to rule-based theory-and perhaps less constrained than models like Lexical Phonology, where the rules are restricted in scope. This equivalence with serial derivational phonology extends to a further issue: a disparate correspondence constraint, for instance, 'stipulates the opaque pattern, rather than explaining it' (Kager 1999: 381).

Shows, this may involve apparent stress shift. ) nana 'mother' guma? ), there is no shift of primary stress. ) a. dankolo 'big' bunlta 'pretty' dankolo + lo 'very big' bunlta + ta 'very pretty' b. ). ) dxla+ la+y 'slender, skinny, thin, slim' diki + ki + 7 'small, little, diminutive' *dcelay *diki? GO-correspondence will work satisfactorily for cases with a free root, since the placement of stress in this independent form can be ascertained and used to determine a match with the reduplicant. However, it clearly cannot be invoked in the bound root Optimality in a Complex World 41 cases; this means no unified account can be given of word-based and root-based reduplication in languages like Chamorro, although these dearly share properties, unless we 'formalize the exclusion of reduplication constraints from the scope of output-output correspondence' (Klein 1997: 713-14).

Download PDF sample

Change, Chance, and Optimality by April McMahon

by Christopher

Rated 4.52 of 5 – based on 45 votes